A CAPPELLA 101
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Guest Bloggers
  • Contact
  • Terms of Service

The Role of Competition in A cappella

2/2/2012

1 Comment

 
The Role of Competition in A cappella
Jonathan Minkoff

SingStrong has embraced competition as one of many opportunities to motivate singers to strive for their best. Yet for many, declaring any meaningful expressiveness the work 
of “losers” seems hopelessly at odds with the very idea of art. 

Still, most people, from trained critics to elementary school kids, have a sense that all art is not created equal. There is some way of measuring one artistic creation against another.

We start with gut associations. These are subconsciously assimilated cultural norms. 
We find that something sounds familiar when it shares traits with other music we know and like. Should the result sound too familiar, we may view the work as unoriginal or predictable. Should it break with all expectation and tradition, we find it meaningless, formless, frustrating, messy or confusing.
 
As an example, many untrained listeners are challenged by the dense harmonies of jazz or the atonality of some contemporary classical music. However, these are by no means fringe art forms because trained listeners –trained either formally or through familiarity- not only appreciate such music, but may be uniquely impassioned by its complexities.

Competitions like SingStrong do present the impossible question of determining whether great barbershop is better or worse than great beatboxing. But as a practical matter, it rarely comes down to that.

Time after time, judges must choose whether charismatically performed simple music is better than less charismatically performed complicated music. (By charisma, I mean the overall impact achieved by the combination of musical and personal expressiveness, not the winning smile of the performer, however charming that might be.)

Of course, the choice needn’t come down to this. Complex music could be delivered with the greater charisma. But, it doesn’t seem to play out this way in reality. And there are logical reasons for this. 

All other things being equal, simpler music allows performers extra rehearsal time to work on performance and showmanship. These performers get to apply significant energies to “selling” their sound rather than only accurately producing it. They get time to become comfortable.

To master complex music, far greater amounts of time need to be devoted to pitch and rhythm. With simpler music, that time can be devoted to dynamics and articulation, musical elements which more easily translate to an energetic, polished and dramatic performance. Complex music demands at least as much, if not more charisma from its performers in order for its impact to be as powerful. Failing that challenge is fatal.

The group that most successfully achieves the very goals that they set for themselves through their musical selections is the group most likely to win a competition. If two groups achieve the same level of success, the one attempting the more challenging, original and entertaining material will most likely be the victor. It is the greater achievement and the riskier gambit.  
1 Comment
Praise
11/14/2022 03:21:05 pm

I need a group I am a great singer with a gud voice

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Jonathan Minkoff
      &  
    Guest Bloggers

    The ultimate "how to" 
    for everything a cappella.


    What's Up?

     We're thrilled at how many views we're getting! (Wow!) But less than 1% comment! What did you think? How can we improve? Post  to let us know! Or contact us here.


    What's Next?

    Recording Tips


    What's Shakin'?

    Let us know all about your latest, greatest a cappella project here.


    Archives

    February 2015
    April 2014
    November 2013
    June 2013
    June 2012
    February 2012
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011


    Categories

    All
    A Cappella
    A Cappella Competition
    Arrangement
    Arrangements
    Arranging
    Cheating
    College Competition
    Compete
    Competition
    Competitions
    Composer
    Compulsory License
    Copyright
    Copyright Act
    Credits
    Digital Download
    Distribution
    Downloading
    Effects
    Effects Pedals
    Fair Use
    Finding A Group To Join
    Free Music
    Fundraising
    Harmony Sweepstakes
    High School Competition
    Legal
    License
    Licensing
    Liner Notes
    Live
    Live A Cappella
    Live Performance
    Mistakes
    Money
    Nbc
    Performance
    Permission
    Philosophy
    Poll
    Public Domain
    Rights
    Season 3
    Singing Competition
    Sing-Off
    Singstrong
    Sonos
    Sony
    Sound Equipment
    Starting Off In A Cappella
    Straight No Chaser
    Streaming
    Technology
    The Sing-Off
    Top 10
    Voca People
    Www.acappella101.com
    X-Factor
    Youtube

    RSS Feed

© Jonathan Minkoff. All rights reserved. Disclaimer
Nothing on this site, whether an article or a comment, or otherwise, is legal or tax advice. It's merely a general discussion of the law. If you have a specific question or situation requiring legal or tax counsel, you need to speak to a specific lawyer, personally, who will ask you specific questions about your specific situation which will allow him or her to do specific research in order to give you specific advice.