A CAPPELLA 101
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Guest Bloggers
  • Contact
  • Terms of Service

Winning: Top 10 A cappella Competition Mistakes

2/23/2015

12 Comments

 
by Jonathan Minkoff 

This article isn't about being the most technically proficient a cappella group. You already know how to do that. This article is about winning. Embrace these ten truths, and don't let them become your ten a cappella competition mistakes!

1. Your Performance Begins the Instant You Step Out on Stage.
The Rules of nearly all a cappella competitions state that the timing begins when you blow the first pitch, begin choreography or start talking. That’s timing. But when does the judging really begin?
 The judges are judging you from the first step you take on stage. Are you setting the mood for your first song? Are you all acting as one, giving off a unified energy? Do you all make eye contact with the audience and each other? Do your faces and body language put the audience at ease because they convey “committed deliberateness”-the sense that everything on stage –even untangling mic chords from the previous group- is precisely what it should be? Pardon the old (and now bastardized) expression, but though you needn’t actually wear pants, you need to wear THE pants. From the instant you enter, you must take the stage. In your body language, you don’t ask to be liked; you tell the audience how great you are, what a good time they’ll have and how you are in charge. And if you do all this before the timer even starts, the judges can’t help but start their scoring with the inclination to love you and everything you do. The alternative is starting from a hole and hoping you can climb out in time for the scoring.

2. You are Not Invisible Before and After the Song.
Your group may divide the show into songs, but we are watching your whole show. The breath you take to begin the ballad. The way you walk towards the mic. The way you gracefully bow after the song has ended and the last reverberation of the final chord fades. Whether you laugh at the joke intro to the next song or whether you are fixing your hair instead and looking concerned that you can’t find your next pitch. We’re always watching. And judges are always scoring.

3. Emote with the Lead, Not With Nonsense Syllables.
Some leads are singing fluff and then the emotion is best described as “Yeah! We’re all having a good time!” That’s fine! You can put that on your face and in your body and all is well. Some leads are singing absolute poetry. What the lead sings, the group must respect. Back-ups that are doing their own thing, particularly when their own thing is distracting or boring are hurting the overall performance. This isn’t to say that the back-ups couldn’t express something different from the lead; they can. But what they express matters and they can’t be in their own world of focusing on “doo doo dah shwah” or the internal monologue of “Hey, do I look fat in these white disco shorts?”

4. “Simple and Perfect” Crushes “Complicated and Almost”.
This is true for all elements of music, but rears its ugly head in Vocal Percussion with great regularity. A deliberate, precise pattern with enough time for your VP to nail each sound and place each sound right in the pocket is infinitely more effective than a sloppy high speed assault. If the sung parts are too hard to sing dead on then they’re not the right choice for competition. We’d rather hear simple perfection. Unlike ice skating’s demands of particular jumps, a cappella competitions usually score you on the goals you set for yourself. Achieve perfection in simpler music and walk away with the trophy. That’s one of the reasons barbershop groups often win or place highly at contemporary competitions: they sing the hell out of the material they’ve chosen, even if the material they’ve chosen is dated or seemingly simple.

5. Never Sing Before You Sing.
Singing the starting chord, or humming before actually starting the song is universally viewed as a weakness in the ability of singers to hear their starting pitches.  Additionally, it’s not a particularly compelling performance choice. And even if you’re lucky enough to have judges that don’t detract points for lack of professionalism or performance, you are still wasting time on something that can never earn you any points.

6. One Talks. One Blows. 
Ron Jeremy jokes aside, laws, sausages and getting the group to sing in the right key and at the right tempo are all mysterious things the people don’t want to see the innards of. We just want them to come out right. Let magicians or politicians teach you the art of distraction then translate that to a cappella. One talks: “Thank you. We are the Flying Noodlebonks. We’d like to show you our spin on some classic 90s alternative music next. Of course I’m referring to the 1890s classic,  ‘I Miss Dear Old Lincoln’! Kick it Noodlebonks!” While One is talking,  Two blows the starting pitch and counts off so that the count off begins before “Kick it Noodlebonks!” and the group starts singing immediately following the talking.  Even if you can’t get it together to time all this right, at the very least don’t have the person intro-ing a song also be the person who blows the pitch and counts off. 

7. Man Cannot Live on Mezzo Forte Alone.
Yes, I know that the original song you’re now covering had no dynamics and they rocked. Too bad. You need dynamics and if you don’t have them, judges will take off points. Songs without dynamics are boring. I’ve never in my life heard a song with too much dynamic range or too much phrasing. 

Many groups think of dynamics as strictly a musical, rather than a performance issue. Consider though, the connection between energy and dynamics. While perfect intonation may take years to achieve, both energy and dynamics can reach exceptional levels of expressiveness after a single focused rehearsal. Even grade school children know how to modulate their voices from incredibly soft to incredibly loud. Dynamics translate to energy and energy translates to excitement in the song and attention in the listener. We hear the change in volume, the phrasing, and the most powerful element of music leaps from the page: motion! So stop deliberately standing still, musically.

8. Tessitura Beats Range.
There may be nothing worse than hearing a tenor pressing grapes for a strained high note, a soprano warding dogs off with her high screech or a bass burping out gravel for the low note. Competitions are not the time for taking long shots. Choose songs that feature your strengths and hide your weaknesses.  Change keys from the original. Make part of the solo into a sectional part. Do whatever you need to do to show us nothing but your good side. Judges never take points off for the high C you didn’t try to hit, only for the one you bungled. Keep each voice in its best tessitura.

9. Talking Doesn’t Win Singing Competitions.
Got a funny bit you like to do in between songs? That’s nice. We do like to see your personality and get to know you, but get to it and get singing. Funny one liners can get the job done just as well as skits and in a fraction of the time, leaving you time to gather points by actually singing.

10. Originality Counts and then Counts Again.
Nearly every competition awards original arrangements and original songs. Why take yourself out of the running for these awards? Also, consider why these awards exist at all: judges and organizers are looking to see the art form move forward and evolve. You can’t do that with well-known arrangements of well-known covers.  And the originality awards aside, as between two groups of approximately equal performance, the judges will break the tie in favor of the more original. 

Think you’ve heard “Insomniac” or “Africa” a few times? Wanna guess how often we judges have heard it? Do you want to take the chance that your arrangement and your performance of this classic are better than any of the thousands we’ve already heard? Gamblin’ man, are ya? It’s a long shot. By contrast, if we’ve never heard the arrangement or the song, then we have fewer preconceived notions of how you are supposed to sing it. You become free to express your creativity instead of your mimicry. 

One of the reasons we are judges is the fact that we’ve heard so much a cappella. So would you rather be a breath of fresh air, turning heads and raising eyebrows or just another in a long line of sleepy Lion Sleepers and worn out Runaround Sues? Go ahead and do those songs in your live shows if you like. They’re tried and true crowd-pleasers and if you are a young singer, then chances are you’re not bored out of your brains from water-torture-like repetition. Just remember that competitions are a different beast, altogether, though so know enough a cappella history to take a pass on the passé.

In Conclusion.
The fundamentals are the necessary building blocks on which your performance stands. If you can’t tune, blend and balance, you won’t win. But that’s not the whole game. Heed this article’s advice and you’ll have easily sidestepped some serious a cappella land mines. When it’s neck and neck, you’ll pull ahead. When you put commitment in your face and body, that can’t help but become a part of your singing. And sometimes, really great stage presence and performance is so powerful, that judges think the musicality is at a higher level than it really is. It’s a multi-pronged attack. It worked in the American Revolutionary War and it works in a cappella! See you at the next competition, you champion, you!  
12 Comments
how to wear chinos link
6/28/2012 12:25:58 pm

your blog is amazing. new follower!

Reply
shopgirl
2/7/2013 06:20:55 am

Great article! Thanks for the barbershop shout out - each genre has so much we can learn from each other. I love the way the lines are blurring a bit as we all are learning to play together.

Reply
Jonathan Minkoff link
2/7/2013 08:51:42 am

I couldn't agree more! If you check out www.SingStrong.org, you'll see a festival with a best of both worlds approach. One of the 2013 classes is actually called "What Barbershop Remembers that Contemporary Forgot". The concert line-ups are pretty spectacular too! Hope to see you there!

Reply
stretchy magic reviews link
8/20/2013 04:24:28 pm

A cappella is one of a kind art form and there are no other art forms to compare with it. Without musical instruments and all, the performance is spectacular. Thank you for writing about the mistakes in a cappella during performances.

Reply
Jonathan Minkoff
2/23/2015 02:41:05 am

This article got a lot of shares recently and those came with quite a few requests for the following info so here it is:

SingStrong a cappella festival March 6, 7, 8 Reston, VA http://dc.singstrong.org/overview.html 10 headliners. 5 concerts. 2 days of classes. 2 afterglows. Free parking. $99 5-star hotel. Free shuttle service. Awesome OPEN group for you to perform with on mic, on the MainStage. Also, open mic afterglow. See Ensamble Fenix (Venezuelan Jazz), Vocaldente (German Swing & Comedy), Anna-Maria Hefele (Austrian Overtone singer), Blue Jupiter (NYC's high energy pop and twisted broadway; voices of Oreo, Nickelodeon, Nokia, CollegeHumor.com), Resound (the gospel group Ariana Grande tweeted about, feat on ABC), Apollo Link (aka The Spideyboys), The Harmonizers (international award-winning barbershop), Ball in the House (Boston's R&B), Traces from NBC's The Sing-Off, Feedback (Jazz influenced R&B) and literally DOZENS more. Also, at the festival, we raise money for local music programs and for the Alzheimer's Association. Get $15 and up tix to individual events, or A WEEKEND PASS to EVERYTHING for as low as $75. BOOM. Do it.

Reply
Jonathan Minkoff
2/23/2015 02:47:55 am

www.SingStrong.org will give you complete info on both the DC and Chicago festivals.

Reply
chuck kenney link
2/23/2015 02:28:39 pm

I'm a cellist (sitting principal chair) a bass in a quartet, a retired 39 year public school music teacher (of orch. choir, band, gen. music)arranger of 3 vol. of string instruction books, 8 year arranger of music for my cello trio (about 500+ songs) and sing with a range from A below low-c to A just under HIGH-C.. i can put my yeah for this article, and i hope more of the needed ''helpful hints'' get published - more importantly , dir. AND SINGERS believe in putting these tips into their own chorus/qtet... most often singer believe they don't need this but use their own 'experience' and ability to DECIDE Which way to leap... I have tried in my chorus to ''suggest'' these things, but well-meaning ''leaders'' do their own routine, get the same results, but tell the chorus WE ARE IMPROVING (when these ''tips'' aren't taken to heart..) BUT, THANKS FOR KEEPING THIS INFO COMING.. ONCE SAID, is not enough reinforcement...

Reply
Jonathan Minkoff
2/24/2015 12:44:18 am

Chuck,

Thanks for the kind words. Your comment actually gave me an idea for another article about the best ways to get the message across. Thanks! Now I have to find time to write that one up!

Reply
Sue Raabe link
2/28/2015 11:43:42 am

This was very informative, and condenses most of what we've been told into one place. Is it possible to share the link to it on my page? I think it would be interesting to the members of my chorus. Even though some of this has been mentioned before, it doesn't hurt to to hear it again? I'll wait for a reply before posting the link, in case that isn't permissible. Thanks for making this information available!

Reply
Jonathan Minkoff
2/28/2015 01:54:13 pm

Sue,

You are absolutely welcome to link to this article. Please encourage your singers to comment about their experiences. All the best! -Jonathan

Reply
Dee
6/3/2018 05:15:17 pm

I play no instruments but i write music similar to how Michael Jackson i think dis it and many other artist, maybe not as good(lol) but i try and i have the melody, and make all beats and sounds with my voice and foundation and so all i would need is the music. so if i send someone to write music to this( arrange it i guess) will they be entitled to royalties?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQuKbzWHvIo

Reply
North Carolina link
2/23/2021 06:30:01 am

Hi niice reading your blog

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Jonathan Minkoff
      &  
    Guest Bloggers

    The ultimate "how to" 
    for everything a cappella.


    What's Up?

     We're thrilled at how many views we're getting! (Wow!) But less than 1% comment! What did you think? How can we improve? Post  to let us know! Or contact us here.


    What's Next?

    Recording Tips


    What's Shakin'?

    Let us know all about your latest, greatest a cappella project here.


    Archives

    February 2015
    April 2014
    November 2013
    June 2013
    June 2012
    February 2012
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011


    Categories

    All
    A Cappella
    A Cappella Competition
    Arrangement
    Arrangements
    Arranging
    Cheating
    College Competition
    Compete
    Competition
    Competitions
    Composer
    Compulsory License
    Copyright
    Copyright Act
    Credits
    Digital Download
    Distribution
    Downloading
    Effects
    Effects Pedals
    Fair Use
    Finding A Group To Join
    Free Music
    Fundraising
    Harmony Sweepstakes
    High School Competition
    Legal
    License
    Licensing
    Liner Notes
    Live
    Live A Cappella
    Live Performance
    Mistakes
    Money
    Nbc
    Performance
    Permission
    Philosophy
    Poll
    Public Domain
    Rights
    Season 3
    Singing Competition
    Sing-Off
    Singstrong
    Sonos
    Sony
    Sound Equipment
    Starting Off In A Cappella
    Straight No Chaser
    Streaming
    Technology
    The Sing-Off
    Top 10
    Voca People
    Www.acappella101.com
    X-Factor
    Youtube

    RSS Feed

© Jonathan Minkoff. All rights reserved. Disclaimer
Nothing on this site, whether an article or a comment, or otherwise, is legal or tax advice. It's merely a general discussion of the law. If you have a specific question or situation requiring legal or tax counsel, you need to speak to a specific lawyer, personally, who will ask you specific questions about your specific situation which will allow him or her to do specific research in order to give you specific advice.